TOP STORIES
-

Give Lupe A Standing Ovation For “SLR 3 (Round of Applause)” -

Jay Electronica, Rap Game Lamar Odom? -

Joe Budden’s “Lost Control (Kendrick Response)”: The Best (And Last?) Of The “Control” Responses -

Fails of the Week: The Harriet Tubman Sextape, Budden’s (Non) “Control” Response & More -

Also Booty: Here’s Video of Iggy Azalea Dry-Humping Her Back-Up Dancers
|
|
Meet The Most Unclearable Samples All-Star SquadPosted by Nathan S. on 05/30/13 | Filed under Opinion, Production Breakdown, Rap Nerdery |

So that got me thinking...there's absolutely a category of artists whose samples are essentially unclearable, but I'm not sure if anyone has ever just laid them down. Sounds like a job for RefinedHype Nation's rap nerds department. I already got some dope feedback via Twitter, sounds like a full article is needed. Challenge accepted.
Having a convo with @djbooth - what's the most unclearable sample of all-time? I say the Beatles.
— Refined Hype (@refinedhype) May 29, 2013
First, some background. We're obviously only talking about tracks for sale or tracks on for purchase albums (aka tracks that need samples cleared). There are thousands of mixtape joints floating around with Elvis and Beatles mash ups, putting an Elvis sample on your album is a whole other ballgame. Although as a great litmus test, the artists who are truly the toughest to clear shut down free shit too (aka The Beatles weren't having any of Laws' Paul McCartney mixtape, that shit got cease and desisted out of existence, Lord Finesse vs. Mac Miller, etc.).
Second, I know this will be common knowledge to many, but not all. Feel free to skip this paragraph, otherwise keep reading. To oversimplify, music publishing means the process of selling the right for music to be used in other songs, commercials, movies, etc. Some artists control 100% of their own publishing. If someone wants to sample their music or put their song in a movie, they get to decide if the placement represents them well, and they collect all the money. Some artists have sold all of their publishing to someone else; they get paid upfront, but they lose control over where their work appears and only get a percentage of the money. Unless their lawyers are morons, most (but not all) major artists have some combination of the two. They signed a publishing deal, but they retain the right to approve placements. There are a million shades of grey in between, but you get the general idea. To make this simple, unless I note otherwise, I'm treating each artist as if they own all of their own publishing. But regardless if the "no" is coming from the artist, the publisher or some combination of both, ultimately it's the "no"s that matter.
Third, so everyone knows how sample clearance really works, yes, it's about money. You're going to have to pay for the good shit, but more than money, it really is about relationships and about the quality of the song. For example, Janet Jackson** is one of the most famous and rich artists on the planet. The damage an association might do to her reputation just isn't worth it for her to let some shitty rapper sample her for a strip club anthem. And even if the song's great, is Janet really picking up the phone for an indie Kendrick?
But when Jimmy Iovine personally calls, and he's got a check, and the song's great? Sure, fine, Janet's cool with "Poetic Justice". Similarly, it wasn't money that cleared the "Annie" sample on "Hard Knock Life", it was Jay-Z personally writing a letter to the songwriters. They were so impressed that it meant that much to him, they cleared the sample.
In summary, even more than money, it's relationships that really matter. And with that, let's go...
The Beatles:
The Beatles are the most automatic money in music. It's been decades since they last put out an album, and their albums and singles still sell thousands of copies a year. That's exactly why they refused to put their music on iTunes for so long - they were still selling a ridiculous amount of hard copies in stores long after other artists had seen their physical copy sales essentially die.
There's some murkiness over who owns what percentage of The Beatles publishing, Sony ATV has at least 50% with the rest divided among multiple parties, but whatever. The point is iTunes, one of the most powerful companies in the world, could barely get The Beatles to let them use their image/song for a commercial, let alone individual artists.
To date, the only Beatles sample I've ever heard used is "My Guitar Gently Weeps" on Wu-Tang's "My Heart Gently Weeps". It's not clear if that's an actual sample or an interpolation**, but either way, RZA must be besties with Paul McCartney or some shit, because he essentially pulled off the impossible. I'd love to hear the story of how that sample got cleared.
I should pause here to offer up a disclaimer. Someone pointed out to me that there are multiple Beatles samples on the Beastie Boys' "Paul's Boutique", and they're right, but first, that album probably contains more samples than any other, and two, in the '80s and early '90s clearing samples was a different ballgame. Then, hip-hop was so commercially small most publishers didn't even bother to sue for infringing samples, if they could even listen close enough to find them, and so many labels didn't bother clearing samples. My the mid-90s though it had become much more difficult to clear a sample, and now that music sales are down and publishing is an increasingly large part of an artists' revenue stream, it's nearly impossible to use an uncleared sample without getting sued. There's exactly a zero percent chance "Paul's Boutique" could be made today. Zero. So in fairness, we'll focus on post-2000 samples. Back to the main topic at hand...
The moral of the story: unless you're RZA, don't sample The Beatles and think you're going to clear the sample. That shit ain't happening. Period.
Prince:
Simply put, Prince does not give a fuck. He changed his name to a symbol and only does same day concerts when he fucking feels like it - do you think he gives a fraction of a shit about the sample on your rap track?
It's not impossible though, there are a handful or rappers who have pulled off clearances from the purple shirted one. Most recently Kanye sampled "It's Gonna Be Lonely" on "Big Brother" and "When We're Dancing Close" for Watch the Throne's "Welcome to the Jungle". Big Boi also grabbed "Automatic" for "Mama Told Me", and pre-2000 there's a pretty solid list of examples (see my point above about how much harder it is now).
The point is Prince is pretty goddamn hard, but it can be done if you're on that Kanye-ish level.
Pink Floyd
Sweet baby jesus Pink Floyd doesn't fuck around. I've heard the cash register opening of "Money" on hundreds of free joints, but I'm hard pressed to find a single album example.
I fucking guarantee you 50 Cent has tried to clear a "Money" sample, but he obviously didn't have better luck than anyone else. So...lesson learned, don't sample Pink Floyd. That shit will not go well for you.
The Eagles
I think this one comes to people's mind mostly over the Frank Ocean brouhaha, but while I generally sides with The Eagles on that one, they certainly don't have a track record of being forthcoming with their samples. Post 2000....Limp Bizkit of all people someone managed to pull off a "Life in the Fast Lane" sample on their "Livin It Up" and...that's pretty much the entire list right there.
As long as we're talking that Bizkit joint, I should also point out that prominence of the sample matters. The Eagles sample on that song is in the background for about two seconds. If instead they had made it the most prominent part of the hook, that's a whole different ballgame, and given The Eagles' track record otherwise, it probably doesn't get cleared.
Led Zeppelin
As soon as someone threw out Zep my first thought was, "Didn't Diddy use that sample of 'Kashmir' that one time?" Yep, he sure fucking did, although that was for a movie soundtrack, so it's a bit of a different ballgame. Past that, Game used a sample of "Stairway to Heaven" for "Doctor's Advocate", and Sean Kingston's "Me Love" samples "D'yer Mak'er". JR Rotem produced both of them, he must have a Zeppelin connect.
Past that...
Radiohead
It's a shame because their catalog has some many incredible possible samples, but apparently Thom Yorke gives less than zero fucks. I did manage to find a Willow Smith single that samples "Codex", but it looks like it has yet to be made an official single or included on an album; maybe because of sample clearance issues.
On a related note, given their "indie" tendencies, I'd be willing to bet Radiohead owns 100% of their publishing, or something close to it. Hence the complete lack of samples - they can't even be influenced by a publisher who owns a percentage and really pushes them to clear.
Any Disney Film Song
I wanted to close with this one because it's a bit of an outlier, it's obviously not an artist, but @ThomasKWelker was completely right. Clearing a sample of any Disney movie song might just be the most impossible sample of them all. That shit IS...NOT...HAPPENING. So, sorry every producer who flipped a dope sample of "Hakuna Matata".
Ok, so to sum up, based on the amount of samples I was album to find, in order from hardest to easiest, my All-Time Hardest Samples to Clear list looks something like this (I'm not including Disney movies):
1) Radiohead
2) Pink Floyd
3) The Eagles
4) The Beatles
5) Led Zeppelin
6) Prince
Really though, you can re-arrange those five in any order and you'd still be pretty right. So there you go producers, you might want to print that list out and put it over your computer. If you sample any of them, you're a dead producer walking. You've been warned.
* The Illuminati are all about brunch, it's a fact.
** Interpolation = replaying or re-singing a song instead of directly sampling the original. Just Blaze interpolates like a motherfucker.
UPDATE: Apollo Brown just did a pretty dope piece on sampling over on DX.
blog comments powered by Disqus
THE BEST OF REFINED HYPE
RefinedHype on Twitter
Tweets by @refinedhype
The Heartbreaking Texting & Driving Documentary That Made Me a Better Man
Rapsody & RefinedHype’s Official Moratorium on the “Femcee”
It’s All Good: Water for Life Brings Kenyan Boy’s Bucket List to Life





