TOP STORIES
-

Heat Check: How Do We Feel About Rick Ross ft. Kanye’s “Sanctified”? -

Lost In Space: Does Hip-Hop Still Care About Kid Cudi? -

SchoolBoy Q’’s “Oxymoron” Album Leaked, Let’s Listen… -

Find Her: Who’s the Girl in ScHoolboy Q’s “Man of the Year” Video? -

Porn Stars in Music Videos: An Absurdly Detailed Investigation
|
|
What the NMPA Lyrics Lawsuit Means for Rap Genius & YouPosted by Nathan S. on 11/13/13 | Filed under Opinion |

Did you hear? RAP GENIUS IS GOING TO BE SHUT DOWN AND SOON YOU WONT EVEN BE ABLE TO TATTOO YOUR FAVORITE SONG LYRICS WITHOUT PAYING FOR THE COPYRIGHT!!!
At least that seems to be the general reaction to the news that the NMPA is moving towards filing a lawsuit, and potentially shutting down, a number of lyrics sites, most prominently including Rap Genius. Now, it should be obvious that I'm no legal expert, my understanding of copyright law is amatuer, but I do happen to be an expert when it comes to music on the internet, so I thought I'd take a shot at breaking down just what's going on, and what it means for Rap Genius and you.
Let's go...
Wait, What the Fuck is Going On?
The National Music Publishers Association (NMPA), which represents over 2500 music publishers and songwriters, is saying that they own the copyright to select song lyrics - which they do.
Since lyric sites like Rap Genius are directly or indirectly making money off those lyrics, they believe they're entitled to a portion of that money, and since Rap Genius is by far the most successful, they're the top target. They've put Rap Genius and others on notice that unless they remove the lyrics, or strike a payment deal with publishers, they'll be hit with copyright lawsuits.
Even if they're able to legally fight off those lawsuits, the prohibitive cost of such a large-scale lawsuit would likely shut many sites down.
Devil's Advocate
I know your gut reaction is probably to say fuck the NMPA, and ultimately I'm inclined to agree, but allow me to play devil's advocate for a moment.
Just about everyone agrees that musicians/labels/publishers should recieve a cut when a site like iTunes, YouTube, Spotify, etc. sells or stream their music. Those sites are directly profiting from the artist's copyrighted music, so how are copyrighted lyrics any different? There's a lot of grey area here, which we'll get to later, but frankly it's a little hypocritical to believe Spotify should pay your favorite artist for streaming his music, but a lyric site shouldn't have to pay to post his lyrics. Fundamentally, what's the difference? (More on the answer to that question later as well.)
Of course we love being able to read lyrics on a site for free anytime we want, but "I want' is not a legal argument. I want to be able to walk into Wells Fargo and walk out with all the cash I can grab, but that shit's not happening.
In good conscience I have to agree that songwriters should be paid for posting lyrics. The question is under what circumstances, how much and what's the best way to make that happen for everyone involved?
What Does RapGenius Have to Say?
Good question, here's the abbreviated response from Rap Genius Co-Founder Ilan Zechory:
“We can't wait to have a conversation with them [the NMPA] about how all writers can participate in and benefit from the Rap Genius knowledge project. Rap Genius is so much more than a lyrics site. The lyrics sites the NMPA refers to simply display song lyrics, while Rap Genius has crowdsourced annotations that give context to all the lyrics line by line...These layers of context and meaning transform a static, flat lyric page into an interactive, vibrant art experience created by a community of volunteer scholars."
It may seem subtle at first, but Zechory is already outlining the crux of what Rap Genius' defense will be, and understanding that defense will go a long way towards addressing the concerns people seem to have about whether they might be sued for posting lyrics on Twitter, if RefinedHype will no longer be able to post and discuss lyrics, etc.
Let's get into some fair use, shall we?
Fair Use
Fair use is a legal doctine that gives some flexibility to copyright. It allows for copyrighted material to be used without permission provided that the use is primarily for "commentary, criticism, news reporting, research, teaching, scholarship, etc."
For example, when Yoh posted some Kanye West lyrics in his "Death By 9-To-5" piece yesterday, that's obvious fair use. He's using the lyrics to help make a much larger point, in the process transforming stand-alone lyrics into editorial (aka commentary and criticism).
By contrast, take those same Kanye West "Spaceship" lyrics on AZLyrics.com. There's no commentary there, no criticism, it'd be much harder for AZLyrics to argue fair use. (To put it less subtley, I think they're fucked.)
Amount also matters. If you post some lyrics you love on your Facebook page, that's fair use, but it's also such a small amount it's insignificant; you're obviously not trying to profit from the lyrics. But when a site has literally thousands of lyrics from thousands of songs, that volume matters.
In other words, this won't affect sites like RefinedHype, your ability to type out lyrics yourself or you, except to the extent that you like to visit lyric sites, and those sites may be shutting down or changing dramatically in the future.
Is Rap Genius in Trouble (aka the Grey Area)?
The short answer is I don't believe so, at least not yet.
Go back and re-read Zechory's statement. See how careful he is to use words like "transform", "scholars", "art" and "context"? It's clear Rap Genius will argue fair use, that because of all the additional material associated with the lyrics, it's actually much closer to an editorial site like RefinedHype than a straight lyrics site like AZLyrics, and therefore protected.
I don't know if I can agree with that argument without reservation, they're obviously and understandably making a self-interested case, but it's certainly a grey area. Rap Genius may be posting a huge volume of lyrics, but there really is constant commentary on those lyrics that would seem to transform them, at least to an extent.
Unlike a lot of other sites, Rap Genius also has very deep pockets - $15 million in VC funding - so even if it comes to a lawsuit, they should be able to fight for an extended time before any ruling comes down. And even if it's determined they have to pay, there's no real agreement about how much a song lyric is worth. It's been generally established that the market rate for selling a song digitally is $1, an album $10, and a song is about $.05 per stream (although that's being hotly contested now). There's not nearly the same agreement about the worth of lyric.
In other words, there's a lot of big and complicated legal questions here, and answering them is going to take a long motherfucking time. While some sites might just decide to cave immediately, don't expect any changes to Rap Genius anytime soon.
In Conclusion
As I mentioned earlier, while I do want to see songwriters get their fair share of the money being made on the interwebs, I do disagree with the NMPA about the best way to get them that money. Let me rephrase that; once again, these morons seem to be more interested in protecting a business model that's clearly dead or dying than helping build their industry for the future.
This seems like just another example of the same "shut down first, ask questions later" mentality that's pervaded the the larger music industry since the Napster days. Rather than viewing Rap Genius as a historically large criminal enterprise, as the NMPA seems to, they should view it as an historically large opportunity.
At the risk of inflating the Rap Genius guys' already seemingly Kanye-esque egos, that site has done more to draw attention to lyrics (aka the work of the songwriters) than anything else ever, in the history of the music industry. It's a massive platform that the industry could have built for themselves, if they weren't ironically so focused on devoting their resources to shutting down sites. Unlike CDs and "illegal" downloads, it wasn't like there was some market for lyrics that existed before the internet that Rap Genius is taking away from.
They should have come to Rap Genius, figured out ways to work with them, spotlight songwriters, better and more directly drive sales of music, etc. But instead the NMPA has come to the negotiating table with a loaded gun, and even if they succeed in shutting down Rap Genius, they'll only end up shooting themselves in the process,and the wound will likely prove to be fatal over the long run. And then everyone loses: the fans, the songwriters, the artists. Well, maybe not everyone. I'm sure there are at least a few old guys pushing for this who will be comfortably retired by the time it becomes clear these lawsuits did more harm than good. They'll probably make out great.
Everyone else though...
THE BEST OF REFINED HYPE
RefinedHype on Twitter
Tweets by @refinedhype
The Best & Worst Rap Lines From Rick Ross’ “Mastermind”
Go DJ: A Tribute to Mannie Fresh
Awesome ‘90s Rap Soundtracks: “Ghost Dog: The Way of the Samurai ” Edition
Who Are The Most Influential Figures In Hip-Hop?






